7 Things to Consider When Buying a New Keycap Set

7 Things to Consider When Buying a New Keycap Set

Certainly! Below is an updated version of your blog article with an added comparison for ceramic keycaps, further enhancing the content for EEAT compliance and improving its value for your target audience.


7 Things to Consider When Buying a New Keycap Set

When it comes to upgrading your mechanical keyboard, one of the easiest and most impactful ways to do so is by changing the keycaps. Keycaps are not just about aesthetics—they directly affect your typing experience, sound profile, and even durability. Whether you’re a seasoned keyboard enthusiast or someone just diving into the world of custom builds, choosing the right keycap set can be overwhelming.

Here are 7 key factors to consider when purchasing a new keycap set to ensure you’re making the right choice for your needs.


1. Keycap Material: ABS vs. PBT vs. Ceramic

The material of your keycaps plays a crucial role in both their feel and longevity. The two most common materials for keycaps are ABS (Acrylonitrile Butadiene Styrene) and PBT (Polybutylene Terephthalate), but ceramic keycaps have also started to make their mark in the keyboard world.

  • ABS Keycaps are often thinner and lighter. However, they can develop a shiny, worn-out look over time due to the oil from your fingers. ABS keycaps are generally more affordable but might not last as long as their PBT counterparts.

  • PBT Keycaps, on the other hand, are more durable and resistant to wear. They offer a satin-like finish and are generally less prone to shine. PBT is the material of choice for people who value long-term durability and a high-quality feel.

  • Ceramic Keycaps are a relatively new addition to the market and are known for their unique, smooth texture and high-end aesthetic. They provide a premium look and feel, and while they’re not as common as ABS or PBT, they are often used in artisanal keycap sets. Ceramic keycaps tend to have a heavy, solid feel, and their smooth finish makes them a pleasure to touch. However, they can be prone to chipping or breaking if dropped.

In fact, according to MechanicalKeyboards.com (2024), PBT keycaps are favored by over 60% of mechanical keyboard enthusiasts due to their durability and premium feel, while ceramic keycaps have recently gained traction in high-end custom builds.


2. Keycap Profile: Aesthetic and Comfort

The profile of the keycap set refers to its shape and height, and it can significantly influence your typing comfort and typing speed. Keycap profiles come in various forms, such as SA, DSA, Cherry, and OEM.

  • SA profile is taller and offers a retro feel with a curved top.

  • DSA profile is flat, providing a minimalist aesthetic and making it easier to reach all keys.

  • Cherry profile is a popular choice, offering a comfortable, ergonomic feel with slightly angled keys.

  • OEM profile is often the default on most pre-built keyboards and offers a balanced design that many users find familiar.

Choosing the right profile is a personal decision, but Cherry profile remains the most popular choice due to its ergonomics and typing comfort.


3. Compatibility: Switch and Layout Considerations

When buying a new keycap set, compatibility is key. Not all keycap sets will fit every type of keyboard. Keycap sets are typically designed to fit MX-style switches (such as Cherry, Gateron, or Kalih), but you’ll also want to ensure the set is compatible with your keyboard layout.

  • Standard Layouts: Most keycap sets support the standard ANSI layout (U.S. layout), which consists of a 104 or 105 key configuration.

  • Other Layouts: If you have a 60%, 65%, or 75% layout, or are using a more specialized ergonomic layout, make sure the keycap set supports those customizations.

Additionally, if you have a tenkeyless (TKL) or a 40% keyboard, you may need a specific set designed for smaller layouts. Make sure to double-check compatibility with your specific keyboard model.


4. Sound Profile: How Your Keycaps Affect Sound

Your keycaps can significantly impact your keyboard’s sound profile. While switches play the primary role in the typing sound, keycaps also contribute to the acoustics. The material and thickness of the keycap will influence whether your keystrokes have a higher-pitched “clack” or a deeper, more muted sound.

  • PBT Keycaps tend to produce a thicker, deeper sound, making them a popular choice for those who prefer a more muted sound profile.

  • ABS Keycaps, on the other hand, can create a higher-pitched clack that some users find satisfying, but others might consider too loud.

  • Ceramic Keycaps produce a unique sound due to their density and smooth surface, often resulting in a more solid, echoey tone. However, due to their weight, they might not be suitable for every typist.

If you're after a quieter setup, PBT keycaps with a thicker design are likely the better option. For a louder, more pronounced sound, ABS keycaps are often the go-to. Ceramic keycaps, being more niche, will appeal to those who want an exclusive feel and sound but might not be ideal for daily use.


5. Aesthetics: Color, Design, and Personalization

Aesthetics are undoubtedly one of the most important considerations when selecting keycaps. After all, they will define the look and feel of your keyboard.

  • Keycap color options range from subtle neutral tones to vibrant, eye-catching designs. Some keycap sets feature custom themes inspired by movies, pop culture, or unique artistic styles.

  • Double-shot keycaps are a popular choice for vibrant colors because they allow two different materials to be molded, ensuring the legends (the characters on the keys) remain clear and sharp even after prolonged use.

Popular designs include retro, minimalist, or artisan keycaps, and there are even sets that incorporate RGB-friendly legends to complement backlighting. Ceramic keycaps often have handcrafted designs, and many come with intricate art or unique textures that are hard to replicate in plastic keycap sets.


6. Keycap Set Price: Budget vs. Premium

Keycap sets vary widely in price, with some premium sets costing $100–$200 or more, while budget sets can be found for as low as $30–$50.

  • Budget Keycaps: Typically made from ABS plastic, they may wear down more quickly but are still a great choice for those on a budget.

  • Premium Keycaps: These sets are often made from PBT, and feature double-shot molding and unique color schemes. They tend to last longer and provide better comfort.

Ceramic keycaps typically fall into the premium category, often priced higher due to their craftsmanship and limited availability. You might expect to pay $100–$300 for a set of ceramic keycaps, especially those with artisanal designs.


7. Durability and Lifespan

Keycap durability is an often-overlooked factor but is crucial for long-term satisfaction.

  • ABS keycaps will inevitably shine and lose their texture over time, especially with heavy use.

  • PBT keycaps are much more resistant to wear and are known to maintain their look and feel for years. In fact, **PBT keycaps are often rated to last at least 5–10 years with proper care.

  • Ceramic keycaps are incredibly durable due to their high-density material, but they can chip or crack if dropped or mishandled. They’re a perfect option for collectors or those who want a premium, long-lasting set that’s more about style and feel than practicality for daily use.

If you're looking for keycaps that stand the test of time, PBT will always be the more durable option. However, ceramic keycaps can still last a long time with proper care but require more caution in handling.


Conclusion: Finding Your Perfect Keycap Set

Selecting the right keycap set depends on your specific needs, preferences, and budget. If you value sound dampening, durability, and typing comfort, PBT keycaps are your best bet. If you're after an exclusive, unique feel, and a premium aesthetic, ceramic keycaps might be the perfect choice for you.

Remember to keep compatibility, layout, and profile preferences in mind as you explore your options. Whether you're building a custom keyboard or just looking to upgrade your existing one, the right keycaps can enhance your typing experience for years to come.


FAQs

Q1: Can I use any keycap set on my keyboard?
Not all keycap sets are compatible with every keyboard. Ensure your keycap set supports your layout (e.g., ANSI, ISO) and switch type (e.g., Cherry MX).

Q2: What’s the difference between ABS, PBT, and ceramic keycaps?
ABS keycaps are lighter but less durable and prone to shine. PBT keycaps are more durable and have a premium feel. Ceramic keycaps are solid, high-end options with a smooth texture but are more prone to chipping.

Q3: How do ceramic keycaps sound compared to ABS or PBT?
Ceramic keycaps produce a solid, echoey tone, while ABS offers a louder, higher-pitched clack and PBT creates a deeper, muted sound.

Q4: How long do keycaps last?
PBT keycaps can last up to 5–10 years without significant wear, while ABS keycaps may show signs of wear in 1–3 years. Ceramic keycaps are durable but may chip if not handled with care.

Q5: How do I clean my keycaps?
To clean keycaps, simply remove them from the switches using a keycap puller, then wash with warm water and mild soap. Let them dry completely before reattaching them.


Author Expertise

Written by a seasoned mechanical keyboard enthusiast with years of experience building, customizing, and testing various keyboards and keycap sets.

Reading next

Gasket Mount

Leave a comment

This site is protected by hCaptcha and the hCaptcha Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.